Legal Framework

The Judiciary System of Pakistan: LEGAL FRAMEWORK

---

1. Overview of Pakistan’s Judiciary System

Pakistan’s judiciary operates under the framework of the Constitution of Pakistan (1973), which provides for the establishment of a system of courts to deliver justice. It is designed to be independent of the executive and legislative branches of government, ensuring a balance of power. The system works to resolve disputes, interpret laws, and protect citizens’ fundamental rights. The judiciary ensures checks and balances by reviewing the constitutionality of laws and executive actions.

---

2. Branches of the Judiciary

The Pakistani judiciary is divided into various branches, each with a specific mandate and jurisdiction. These include:

1. Supreme Court of Pakistan: The apex court at the national level.
2. High Courts: Provincial courts handling regional matters.
3. Lower Courts: District and Sessions Courts, responsible for civil and criminal matters.
4. Specialized Courts: Including Family Courts, Shariat Courts, etc.
5. Anti-Terrorism Courts: Established to address terrorism-related offenses.
6. Labor Courts: Deal with labor disputes and workers’ rights.
7. Environmental Courts: Focus on environmental regulations and cases.

Hierarchy of Courts

The hierarchy of Pakistan’s judiciary is structured as follows:

• Supreme Court of Pakistan (Apex Court)
• High Courts (Provincial Level)
  • District & Sessions Courts
  • Civil Courts
  • Criminal Courts
• Special Courts (Shariat Courts, Family Courts, etc.)

Judicial Powers and Functions

• Judicial Review: The judiciary has the authority to review laws and government actions to ensure their constitutionality.
• Interpretation of Laws: Courts interpret the meaning of the Constitution and statutes, providing clarity in legal matters.
• Civil and Criminal Jurisdiction: Courts handle both civil disputes (e.g., property, contracts) and criminal cases (e.g., theft, assault).

---

3. Federal and Provincial Judiciary

The judiciary in Pakistan is divided into federal and provincial jurisdictions, reflecting the federal structure of the country. The federal judicial system handles cases involving national issues, while the provincial courts focus on regional matters.

Federal Judiciary

The federal judiciary is composed of the Supreme Court of Pakistan, which is the highest court in the country, and other specialized courts such as the Federal Shariat Court and Anti-Terrorism Courts.

1. Supreme Court of Pakistan: It is the highest court, with the power of judicial review. It hears appeals from High Courts and can strike down unconstitutional laws.
2. Federal Shariat Court: This court deals with issues related to Islamic law (Sharia). It also reviews laws to ensure they comply with Islamic principles.
3. Anti-Terrorism Courts: Established under the Anti-Terrorism Act, these courts specifically handle cases related to terrorism, sabotage, and related offenses.

Provincial Judiciary

Each province has its own High Court, which is the highest judicial authority at the provincial level. Below the High Courts are the District and Sessions Courts, Civil Courts, Family Courts, and other specialized courts. Provincial judicial structures are often mirrored to ensure uniformity with federal structures.

1. High Court of Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Balochistan: These courts serve as the highest judicial bodies in their respective provinces.
2. District and Sessions Courts: Handle a wide range of civil and criminal cases.
3. Family Courts: Handle family law cases such as divorce, inheritance, and child custody.
4. Civil Courts: Deal with civil disputes, including property, contracts, and commercial matters.

---

4. Shariat Courts in Pakistan

The Federal Shariat Court is a specialized court in Pakistan that ensures that laws conform to Islamic principles. This court can examine any law to determine whether it is consistent with the principles of Islamic Sharia law. It has the authority to:

• Review laws passed by the Parliament.
• Declare laws unconstitutional if they violate the provisions of Sharia law.
• Provide Islamic rulings in civil, criminal, and family matters.

Additionally, the Shariat Appellate Bench of the Supreme Court hears appeals against decisions made by the Federal Shariat Court.

---

5. Family Courts in Pakistan

Family Courts are specialized courts that deal with matters relating to family law, including:

• Marriage and divorce (e.g., cases of Khula, Talaq)
• Child custody and guardianship
• Inheritance issues
• Maintenance (alimony and child support)

These courts are designed to provide swift resolutions to family disputes, particularly those affecting women and children.

Structure of Family Courts

Family Courts function under the following framework:

• Presiding Officer: Family Courts are typically presided over by judges who specialize in family law.
• Fast-Track Procedures: Family courts often have simplified and expedited procedures to handle sensitive matters quickly.

---

6. Composition of Courts

Each court in Pakistan is composed of a judge or panel of judges. The judges are appointed based on their legal qualifications, experience, and sometimes political considerations. Here’s a look at how different levels of courts are composed:

Court Type	Judges
Supreme Court of Pakistan	Chief Justice and 17 Associate Justices
High Court	Chief Justice and Judges (variable by province)
District and Sessions Court	District Judge (for civil cases) / Sessions Judge (for criminal cases)
Family Court	Presiding Family Court Judge
Special Courts (Shariat, etc.)	Judges specialized in respective fields

---

7. Appointment and Removal of Judges

The President of Pakistan appoints judges to the Supreme Court, High Courts, and other courts on the advice of the Prime Minister. Judges of the Supreme Court are appointed by the Judicial Commission of Pakistan, which is a body consisting of senior judges, politicians, and legal professionals.

Judges can be removed from office by the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) in cases of misconduct, incompetence, or other grounds as provided by the Constitution.

---

8. Systematic Procedures in Courts

The procedural aspects of Pakistan’s judiciary ensure that justice is delivered in an organized and transparent manner. Some of the key procedures include:

• Civil Procedures: Governed by the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), which provides the rules for filing suits, appealing judgments, and resolving civil disputes.
• Criminal Procedures: Governed by the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) and the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), which outline the steps for criminal investigations, prosecutions, trials, and punishments.
• Family Law Procedures: Governed by the Family Courts Act and Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, which deal with divorce, custody, inheritance, and maintenance.

Steps in a Typical Case Procedure

1. Filing a Case: The plaintiff submits a petition or complaint to the appropriate court.
2. Preliminary Hearing: The court assesses whether the case is admissible.
3. Evidence Collection: Both parties present evidence and witnesses to support their claims.
4. Trial: The court evaluates evidence, hears testimonies, and renders a verdict.
5. Appeal: If one party is dissatisfied, they may appeal the decision to a higher court (e.g., High Court or Supreme Court).

---

9. Judicial Review and Role in Politics

Judicial review is a cornerstone of Pakistan’s judicial system. The judiciary has the power to review laws and actions of the executive branch to ensure they do not violate the Constitution. This includes reviewing:

• Acts of Parliament: The judiciary can declare laws unconstitutional if they conflict with the Constitution.
• Executive Actions: The judiciary can scrutinize government decisions, particularly when they violate fundamental rights or exceed legal authority.

Notable Role in Political Landscape

The judiciary has historically played a significant role in Pakistan’s political landscape, from judicial activism in the 2000s to its involvement in political decisions related to military rule and democratic governance. Notable cases include:

• Judicial Intervention in the Musharraf Era: The judiciary played a pivotal role in challenging military rule during the regime of Pervez Musharraf.
• Judicial Review of Election Procedures: The courts often intervene in political matters, including the validation of election processes.

---

10. Conclusion

Pakistan’s judiciary is a multifaceted system designed to administer justice across a range of legal areas. It has a hierarchical structure with several specialized courts addressing various aspects of law, including civil, criminal, family, and Sharia matters. Despite challenges related to delays and political influence, the judiciary remains a central pillar in upholding the Constitution and ensuring that the government remains accountable. With an independent judicial system, Pakistan aims to preserve the rule of law, protect citizens’ rights.